Difference between revisions of "Period by consensus"

From Cunnan
Jump to navigationJump to search
m
 
(3 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Generally, only items considered [[period]] are really accepted at [[SCA]] [[events]]. A few (really useful) items are considered by some to be "in period by consensus" due to the fact that their omission would make life much more difficult and less fun. Items like this may include:
+
Generally, only items considered [[period]] are really accepted at [[SCA]] [[events]]. A few (really useful) items are considered by some to be in '''period by consensus''' due to the fact that their omission would make life much more difficult and less fun. Items like this may include:
 
* [[duct tape]]
 
* [[duct tape]]
 
* [[coffee]] (for non eastern personas)
 
* [[coffee]] (for non eastern personas)
Line 7: Line 7:
 
and many others.
 
and many others.
  
In [[Ealdormere]], several items, including [[chocolate]] and [[coffee]] have been declared '''legally period''', a formal declaration that they are period by consensus.
+
In [[Ealdormere]], several items, including [[chocolate]] and [[coffee]] have been declared "legally period", a formal declaration that they are period by consensus.  In numerous [[kingdom]]s over the years, [[Royal Whim]]s have declared numerous items to be in period - chocolate is a common offender.  It  is worth noting that everyone understands that this is a joke, not an attempt (like [[Canute the Great|King Canute]]'s) to override physics or any sort  of attempt at actual scholarship or re-creation.
  
 
Many (most?) places simply acknowledge that the items are [[out of period]] but use them anyway.  In fact, marking them as "period by consensus" simply highlights their [[OOP]] nature and makes it harder to ignore them.
 
Many (most?) places simply acknowledge that the items are [[out of period]] but use them anyway.  In fact, marking them as "period by consensus" simply highlights their [[OOP]] nature and makes it harder to ignore them.
 +
 +
The term "period by consensus" itself would seem to be a limted regional usage.
 +
 +
This idea is less accepted in [[re-enactment]] groups. Most discourage such behaviour. During [[display]]s such activities are not permitted, and during [[event]]s where they are not on display, only [[cigarettes]] make an appearance and then usually out of sight. This is considered a minor inconvenience to a few and enhances the [[event]] greatly for many.
  
 
[[category:SCAism]]
 
[[category:SCAism]]
 
[[Category:artefact (modern)]]
 
[[Category:artefact (modern)]]

Latest revision as of 02:55, 11 September 2007

Generally, only items considered period are really accepted at SCA events. A few (really useful) items are considered by some to be in period by consensus due to the fact that their omission would make life much more difficult and less fun. Items like this may include:

and many others.

In Ealdormere, several items, including chocolate and coffee have been declared "legally period", a formal declaration that they are period by consensus. In numerous kingdoms over the years, Royal Whims have declared numerous items to be in period - chocolate is a common offender. It is worth noting that everyone understands that this is a joke, not an attempt (like King Canute's) to override physics or any sort of attempt at actual scholarship or re-creation.

Many (most?) places simply acknowledge that the items are out of period but use them anyway. In fact, marking them as "period by consensus" simply highlights their OOP nature and makes it harder to ignore them.

The term "period by consensus" itself would seem to be a limted regional usage.

This idea is less accepted in re-enactment groups. Most discourage such behaviour. During displays such activities are not permitted, and during events where they are not on display, only cigarettes make an appearance and then usually out of sight. This is considered a minor inconvenience to a few and enhances the event greatly for many.