Category talk:Recipes - Revision history

Tobin: :Category:Unredacted recipes and :Category:Recipes?

2004-09-04T04:24:44Z

Category:Unredacted recipes and Category:Recipes?

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:24, 4 September 2004
Line 1:		Line 1:
	I think we should add the sub-category [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] to keep this list a bit tidier (I'm assuming most people don't want to see the unredacted recipes). - [[User:Tobin\|Tobin]] 10:34, 24 Aug 2004 (EST)		I think we should add the sub-category [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] to keep this list a bit tidier (I'm assuming most people don't want to see the unredacted recipes). - [[User:Tobin\|Tobin]] 10:34, 24 Aug 2004 (EST)
	* There is a list of supposedly unredacted recipes on [[Cunnan:Recipes from the Forme of Cury]]. That what I was using the other day to work out which articles didn't have [[:category:recipes]]. I was nowhere near finished on that. Do we really want to shift all of them to a unredacted category? I suspect that people won't remember to shift them into the top category once they have been redacted, making it harder for us who edit stuff like that. I would think that it would be best to just have a category for recipes and one for Forme of Cury. The same article can appear in both. If you can't understand the period recipe, then tough luck! I can't see how a different category is going to change that. - [[User:Cian\|Cian Gillebhrath]]		* There is a list of supposedly unredacted recipes on [[Cunnan:Recipes from the Forme of Cury]]. That what I was using the other day to work out which articles didn't have [[:category:recipes]]. I was nowhere near finished on that. Do we really want to shift all of them to a unredacted category? I suspect that people won't remember to shift them into the top category once they have been redacted, making it harder for us who edit stuff like that. I would think that it would be best to just have a category for recipes and one for Forme of Cury. The same article can appear in both. If you can't understand the period recipe, then tough luck! I can't see how a different category is going to change that. - [[User:Cian\|Cian Gillebhrath]]

			** The list at [[Cunnan:Recipes from the Forme of Cury]] isn't automatically updated whereas [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] would be. As it stands someone would need to edit a recipe article '''and''' [[Cunnan:Recipes from the Forme of Cury]] to alter the list. Much easier to ask them to remember to change [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] to [[:Category:Recipes]]. Another possibility would be putting both [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] and [[:Category:Recipes]] into the articles and removing [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] once a redaction is submitted. We'd get all recipes in the recipes category and still have an automatically updated list of unredacted recipes. - [[User:Tobin\|Tobin]] 14:24, 4 Sep 2004 (EST)

Cian: unredacted recipes

2004-08-24T01:26:00Z

unredacted recipes

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:26, 24 August 2004
Line 1:		Line 1:
	I think we should add the sub-category [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] to keep this list a bit tidier (I'm assuming most people don't want to see the unredacted recipes). - [[User:Tobin\|Tobin]] 10:34, 24 Aug 2004 (EST)		I think we should add the sub-category [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] to keep this list a bit tidier (I'm assuming most people don't want to see the unredacted recipes). - [[User:Tobin\|Tobin]] 10:34, 24 Aug 2004 (EST)
			* There is a list of supposedly unredacted recipes on [[Cunnan:Recipes from the Forme of Cury]]. That what I was using the other day to work out which articles didn't have [[:category:recipes]]. I was nowhere near finished on that. Do we really want to shift all of them to a unredacted category? I suspect that people won't remember to shift them into the top category once they have been redacted, making it harder for us who edit stuff like that. I would think that it would be best to just have a category for recipes and one for Forme of Cury. The same article can appear in both. If you can't understand the period recipe, then tough luck! I can't see how a different category is going to change that. - [[User:Cian\|Cian Gillebhrath]]

Tobin: :Category:Unredacted recipes?

2004-08-24T00:34:26Z

Category:Unredacted recipes?

New page

I think we should add the sub-category [[:Category:Unredacted recipes]] to keep this list a bit tidier (I'm assuming most people don't want to see the unredacted recipes). - [[User:Tobin|Tobin]] 10:34, 24 Aug 2004 (EST)